
State Farm® Insurance Agent Kaitlyn McGilvray
Leave Us a Review
Our customers are the center of our universe and we’re grateful for them. If you’re willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it’ll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.
Take 60 seconds (or more if you want) to share your story by clicking on one of the review links below.
What our customers say about us...
Kelly O'Malley
April 19, 2025
"I had an excellent experience working with Aaron Pawlik at Kaitlyn McGilvray State Farm. I needed to get car insurance for my 16-year-old daughter, who just got her license, and Aaron was incredibly helpful and patient throughout the entire process. He walked me through all the coverage options, making sure we had the right protection for a new driver. Adding a teen to a policy can be overwhelming, but Aaron made everything smooth and stress-free. He also took the time to review all my existing vehicle policies, ensuring I was getting the best price and coverage possible. His knowledge, attention to detail, and genuine care gave me complete peace of mind. On top of that, he secured us a great rate! I highly recommend Aaron for anyone looking for a seamless and professional insurance experience."
"Thank you Kelly!! We appreciate you and your fam very much!! Tell your teen, I’ll be watching them on the road 🤪"
Ralf Schurmann
April 9, 2025
"Worked with Kalley at the office and she did an amazing job! Good quotes that were honest and straightforward and beat the competition by a mile price wise. Highly recommended!"
"Thank you Ralf! We can’t always save customers money but we dance when we do! Kalley is terrific! "
Vincent Mahoney
April 9, 2025
"I’ve been working with Chrissy at this State Farm for a few years now. I could not recommend better service! She is always so helpful and willing to put in the extra work!"
"Wow! Thank you! She truly is a rock star! Glad to have you back! "
Leah Burns
March 27, 2025
"Chrissy assisted me with a new homeowners policy for my condo. The process was so easy, she had everything worked out that all I had to do was review it and give it the green light. Communication was excellent throughout. The price was also excellent, it actually was HALF the price of what another company (that I use for auto, but not for long) quoted me! I appreciate how easy this was in the middle of all the stress of home buying. Thank you!!"
"Thank you so much Leah! Chrissy truly loves helping people with their insurance and trying to make it as easy as possible! Glad you had such a wonderful experience. "
Lisa Thibodeaux
March 26, 2025
"Kaitlyn and her team, were very professional and efficient. Saved us hundreds of dollars in car and home insurance. Very happy to be with them!!"
"Thank you Lisa! Thankful to have you both as customers for now and hopefully ever :) "
jason west
February 19, 2025
"Chrissy was fantastic to work with, and I was able to save over 50% on my auto insurance with State Farm!"
"Thank you so much Jason! Welcome! "
Tyler Pepper
February 15, 2025
"My family and I sought out for life insurance and Chrissy went above and beyond to go over every detail of the process! She made the entire experience seamless for us all! We had a policy in less than 24 hours!! 😊 Great policies and VERY affordable! I now have a plan in place that I can convert at any point without rate changes or hidden small print details! Thank you Chrissy and all of the State Farm family!❤️"
"Thank you Tyler for allowing us to protect your family in the most important of ways! Chrissy is #1 is our books !!"
Dee Thomas
February 5, 2025
"It was so easy to get signed back up and add the coverage that we wanted. I love working with state farm. When ever I call in with a question they have a answer and make sure I'm good with everything."
"Thank you for this review! We’re excited to have you back with our fam! "
Allen Ninofranco
February 5, 2025
"Chrissy was great to work with getting our auto and home insurance set up."
"Thank you so much for this review! We’re glad to have you!! "
Andrea Kawagley
February 5, 2025
"Very helpful and had timely responses. :)"
"Thank you so much! Means a lot and happy to have you as a customer ! "
Paul Rhodes
January 24, 2025
"Chrissy worked with me on this. Very happy with the results. Much better than other Pet Insurance I've used. Very professional atmosphere in their office."
"Thank you Paul!!! Appreciate the positive review and thanks for allowing us to protect Lucy! "
Laurel Pfanmiller-Azegami
January 12, 2025
"When my State Farm agent in Anchorage retired, my insurance policies were transferred to Kaitlyn McGilvray's, whose office is in Wasilla. Since I live close to 40 miles away in Anchorage, I considered requesting the polices to be transferred to an agent located a mile from my home, but decided to give her office a try. I am happy that I did. From my very first phone call, I have found the office staff kind and responsive to my needs, whether it is to answer my questions, assist with new policies or respond to left phone messages. I look forward to a long term relationship with this agent and her staff."
"Wow that’s so much Laurel! We are absolutely honored to have you as a customer now and for many years to come! Thank you for your trust . "
Kirsten Berg
January 10, 2025
"Kaitlyn is a very knowledgeable insurance agent who is always willing to work with you, with a smile!"
"Thank you Kirsten! Happy to have you on board ❤️"
Joseph Narum
December 27, 2024
"Moved to Alaska from Tucson and she was very helpful to my wife and I. Like hitting the easy button"
"Thank you so much !! Glad to have you And hope you’re braving the climate change 🤪"
Shelley Ballou
October 25, 2024
"Professional staff who is always there to answer any questions that I might have about my policies."
"Thank you so much for your review! Means a lot and we’re grateful to have you! ❤️"
Frances Walker
October 25, 2024
"Kaitlyn has helped many Care Coordination Agencies find the correct Work Comp & Liability Insurance when other agencies could not find the information. She has also freely shared her information with her competitors to help out her community members. She stands up for her employees, her customers and her community members."
"WOW! Thank you so much for this review. Truly love serving the community. "
Lexi B
October 25, 2024
"Kaitlyn is an amazing agent! I can tell that she actually cares about her customers and goes above and beyond for them!! Highly recommend Kaitlyn and her team!!"
"Thank you Lexi! Appreciate the support. "
Jesse Tigner
October 25, 2024
"Kaitlyn and her team have been our life Insurance providers for several years. They have consistently answered questions, offered advice, and helped us when we needed to update anything. I would trust Kaitlyn with any insurance needs because she has proven herself time and time again. In addition, Kaitlyn loves the community and consistently puts on community events that are great for kids and adults alike! Thank you Kaitlyn for all you do!"
"Thank you sir… the support means the world!! "
Kelsie McKnight
October 25, 2024
"We use Kaitlyn McGilvray with State Farm for personal and both of our businesses. Not only is she professional but her attention to detail is spot on. She finds ways to save us the most money while still having the best coverage for our family and businesses. Highly recommend!"
"Thanks Kels. Love insuring your fam and watching both of your businesses thrive!"
Trish Bras
October 25, 2024
"Kaitlyn and her team are always so eager to help and absolutely amazing! Professional atmosphere and will get you the best price possible!"
"Thank Trish!! Hope you’re doing well!"
Sherese Miller
October 25, 2024
"Wonderful, genuine and knowledgeable agent who loves to give back to the community and support other small businesses. You can’t go wrong with someone like Kaitlyn who’s not only an expert in her field but truly a kind human with the biggest heart. I wouldn’t take my business elsewhere."
"The sweetest! Thank you! ❤️🫶🏼"
Elizabeth Welsh
October 25, 2024
"Kaitlyn and team are the best! Knowledgeable and friendly and their generosity is unmatched. They are dedicated to giving back to the community and it shows :)"
"Thank you! Love your family!"
Robbie Southards
October 25, 2024
"Great professional and welcoming staff. I came in for some questions and advice and they helped me out. Will go again. (Picture of Hawaii beach for attention)"
"Thanks Rob!!! Appreciate you ❤️❤️"
Tyler Scanlan
October 25, 2024
"I’ve had car and home insurance with Kaitlyn’s office for 2 years now and her staff has been nothing but helpful, they also set up my family with some great Life Insurance options too! Thanks, Kaitlyn!!"
"Thank you Tyler !!!"
Lynette Ortolano
October 25, 2024
"Best team of agents in Alaska! Always responsive, Always knowledgeable and ridiculously helpful!!!"
"Thank you! We’ve enjoyed helping you over the years!!"